An injury claim may result in the awarding of various types of damages to the plaintiff for the injuries caused by the defendant’s negligence. Damages can be compensatory damages and punitive damages. Compensatory damages are meant as compensation to the injured party, while punitive damages are meant as a deterrent. One needs to understand the difference when navigating personal injury claim
If you are suing a party for a car accident, typically you will ask for compensatory damages for medical bills, wage loss, pain and suffering, and property damage. If the offending party’s behavior was particularly reckless, the court may award punitive damages as punishment. The purpose of these awards, calculations, burdens of proof, and limitations are different.
What Are Compensatory and Punitive Damages?
Punitive damages serve three main purposes:
- Punishment: Penalize for the reckless and wrongful behavior.
- Deterrence: Discourage the defendant from repeating similar conduct.
- Caution to society: To warn society that certain behaviors will not be tolerated and will attract dire consequences.
Compensatory damages, or actual damages, are compensation to the injured party for the losses suffered due to the wrongful act. The goal is to compensate the plaintiff financially and non-financially for the loss due to the injury.
The Role and Nature of Damages
Punitive damages are not compensation but punishment or a deterrent. It is awarded along with compensatory damages. If the defendant’s conduct is found to be reckless, malicious, or willfully endangering to others, courts require clear and convincing evidence for punitive damages.
The plaintiff should prove beyond a doubt that the defendant’s action was egregious in nature. Punitive damages are awarded rarely, in a very small percentage of civil cases.
Compensatory damages are divided into:
- Economic Damages: Covers hospital bills, future medical care, rehabilitation costs, loss of income or earning capacity, repair or replacement of damaged property, and other out-of-pocket expenses.
- Non-economic Damages: Covers intangible losses, such as pain and suffering, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, disfigurement, or loss of consortium.
Compensatory damages cover actual losses and are calculated based on tangible evidence, such as medical records, bills, pay stubs, expert testimony, and valuations of future care. These papers are examined thoroughly by the court and insurance companies. Once causation and damages are established, quantified compensatory damages are awarded in successful personal injury claims.
Key Differences in Purpose, Calculation, and Limits
| Feature | Compensatory Damages | Punitive Damages |
| Purpose | Reimbursement and compensation for the plaintiff | To punish and deter wrongful conduct |
| Basis | Losses proven via evidence | Magnitude of misconduct, financial condition of the accused |
| Standard of Proof | Preponderance of evidence | Clear and convincing evidence (higher standard) |
| Frequency | Very common | Rare |
| Ratio or Cap | No cap, but subject to causation limits | Capped or ratio relative to compensatory damages as per state laws |
| Tax Treatment | Generally not taxed | Taxable as income to the plaintiff |
As punitive damages are not awarded in proportion to the plaintiff’s loss, courts have placed a cap to avoid high amounts as damages. Many states have imposed statutory capping or maximum acceptable ratios.
In some states, punitive damages are limited, disallowed, or governed under specific legal frameworks. In certain states, they are prohibited entirely, while in others they are subject to strict rules regarding awarding.
Summary
- Compensatory and punitive damages have distinct purposes in injury claims.
- Compensatory damages are awarded to restore the victim’s economic and non-economic losses.
- Punitive damages are awarded for misconduct that exceeds ordinary negligence, serving as punishment and to deter future wrongdoing.
- Punitive awards are rare, require irrefutable proof, and are governed by statutory and constitutional limits. They are awarded after significant legal and strategic considerations.
- Understanding these differences will help when evaluating, negotiating, or litigating personal injury claims.
More Stories